Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, My Indoor Space earns from qualifying purchases through links in this article, at no extra cost to you.
Quick verdict
Choose the OXO expandable organizer for a mixed drawer of cutlery and awkward kitchen tools. Choose the original Joseph Joseph compact DrawerStore when narrow width is the problem and you have at least 8 cm of internal clearance. A drawer that barely closes is a failed fit, however neat the organizer looks.
Research-based buying guide. Product information checked October 16, 2026. We have not tested these products hands-on; recommendations distinguish published features from our practical buying judgments.
OXO expandable organizer
Joseph Joseph compact DrawerStore
These organizers solve different space problems. OXO spreads utensils across an adjustable tray. Joseph Joseph angles and overlaps cutlery compartments to use less width. Before comparing prices, work out whether your drawer lacks width, height or a sensible division between everyday items and occasional gadgets.
Choose by the drawer you have
| Your drawer | Better starting point | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Wide, with flatware and can openers | OXO expandable | Open areas accommodate mixed tool shapes |
| Narrow, mainly standard cutlery | Compact DrawerStore | Overlapping compartments save width |
| Less than 8 cm usable height | Neither without further checks | The cited DrawerStore requires more clearance; assess a low tray |
| Oversized serving utensils | Open dividers or a separate section | Compact flatware slots may be unsuitable |
What OXO adds
The Good Grips expandable model includes utensil caddies, an open area for irregular tools and a small removable cup for items such as wine stoppers. OXO also lists removable trays for cleaning and non-slip feet. Its appeal is flexibility within one drawer rather than the smallest possible footprint.
That is useful when forks and spoons share a drawer with a corkscrew, can opener or measuring tools. The trade-off is that an expandable tray still consumes its own minimum width. It cannot rescue a drawer narrower than the organizer’s closed dimensions.
Choose this layout if you want to see and reach the different groups without lifting several utensils out of an angled slot. Skip it if the extra compartments will simply collect gadgets you never use. Empty the drawer and remove duplicates before measuring for a larger organizer.
What the compact DrawerStore adds
The original grey model, SKU 85119, stacks cutlery positions at an angle. Joseph Joseph lists a body approximately 39.5 cm long, 11 cm wide and 5.7 cm high, but specifies a drawer with a minimum height of 8 cm. The required clearance is greater than the plastic body’s height because the cutlery must also fit.
This is a good example of a specification that changes a purchase. A drawer 6 cm deep may appear to accept the empty tray while failing once knives or spoon handles are loaded. Measure the usable clearance under the cabinet frame, not only the height of the drawer’s wooden side.
Do not apply those measurements to every DrawerStore. Expandable, bamboo, knife-storage and newer versions are separate products. Check the SKU and dimensions of the listing you intend to buy.
Visibility is the main compromise
Angled storage can make different utensils less immediately distinguishable. The compact tray uses cutlery icons, but icons do not guarantee that a guest will grab the right item on the first attempt. That may be a minor learning curve for one person and an annoyance in a busy family kitchen.
Owner feedback on Joseph Joseph’s page includes praise for space savings and a report of cutlery catching when the drawer opens. Those accounts do not establish a failure rate. They reinforce the practical need to test a loaded drawer slowly during the return window.
A five-minute fit test
- Measure inside width and depth at their narrowest points.
- Measure clearance beneath the frame and any drawer above.
- Lay out your longest knife, tallest spoon stack and largest utensil.
- Make a paper outline of the organizer’s footprint.
- Check what remains accessible beside and behind that outline.
If the leftover strip is too narrow to hold anything useful, a compact organizer may not create as much usable space as the advertising image suggests. Conversely, filling every centimetre with a large expandable tray may prevent you from storing a bulky item that needs an open corner.
Cleaning and long-term value
Joseph Joseph specifies handwashing and drying for the cited compact model. OXO describes trays that lift out for cleaning. Check the care label on the exact version; removable does not automatically mean dishwasher safe.
Crumbs and droplets accumulate where utensils enter compartments. Buy a design you can clean without an elaborate disassembly routine. Dry cutlery before putting it away, and avoid treating a drawer organizer as a knife block unless it is specifically designed to protect sharp blades.
When to pay more, and when to spend nothing
Pay for the compact DrawerStore if it frees enough width for another genuinely useful storage section. Pay for OXO if its open compartments let you organize mixed tools without adding a second tray. A cheaper flat tray is enough if your drawer already has plenty of width and only needs separation.
For Canadian orders, check centimetres against the listing’s inch measurements and compare delivered CAD prices. Buying a U.S. listing with expensive return shipping is particularly poor value when fit is uncertain. Neither organizer requires drilling or a permanent change to the cabinet.
Final choice
OXO is the better fit for mixed utensils; the compact DrawerStore is the better fit for a narrow cutlery drawer with sufficient height. Measure first, test with your actual utensils, and keep only the design that opens and closes cleanly when loaded.
Compare current listings in your country
These buttons open matching Amazon search listings, not a guaranteed in-stock offer. Check the exact model, included parts, seller, delivery total and return terms before buying. U.S. and Canadian offers can differ.
OXO expandable organizer
Joseph Joseph compact DrawerStore