As an Amazon Associate, My Indoor Space earns from qualifying purchases.
Quick verdict
Choose the standard OXO Brew Conical Burr for its remembered timer setting and an everyday filter-coffee routine when it costs less. Choose the standard Baratza Encore when parts access, repair documentation and continued maintenance matter more. If espresso is the main task, compare a purpose-oriented grinder rather than treating either standard model as the automatic choice.
Research-based buying guide, checked October 18, 2026. We have not tested these products hands-on. Manufacturer specifications and attributed outside findings are distinguished from our buying judgments.
Who should buy or skip
Buy if: you make filter coffee regularly and want adjustable burr grinding without moving to a complicated appliance.
Skip if: you mainly want a built-in scale, precise espresso adjustments or a silent grinder; those are different purchase requirements.
Compare the choices
| Choice | Choose it for | Main tradeoff |
|---|---|---|
| OXO Brew 8717000 | Remembered timed grinding | Time is not a measured dose |
| Baratza Encore ZCG485 | Manual operation with a documented parts ecosystem | Repairability still involves parts, work and possible service cost |
| Espresso-oriented grinder | Fine adjustment for a demanding shot workflow | May cost more than a filter-first setup needs |
Timer convenience versus weighing the dose
OXO’s one-touch timer remembers its previous setting. That is convenient if you use similar beans and make a similar batch each morning. It does not weigh the coffee: a different roast or grind setting can change how much reaches the container in the same time.
Baratza lists the Encore’s dosing as manual. If you already weigh each dose, the OXO timer may be less important than it first sounds. Decide whether you want a repeatable time shortcut or a weigh-before-and-after routine.
More numbered settings do not prove a better cup
OXO lists 15 settings plus intermediate adjustments; Baratza lists 40 individual settings. The numbers belong to different adjustment systems and do not form a shared quality score. The useful question is whether you can find and repeat an appropriate grind for your brewer.
TechGearLab’s original comparative testing found both capable for their price class and flagged more mess for the standard OXO. That is outside testing, not our result, and it is a reason to inspect cleanup rather than assume either grinder is mess-free.
Repair support is part of the Encore argument
Baratza publishes Encore documentation and sells model-specific parts. That gives a maintenance-minded owner something concrete to check before buying: which parts can be ordered locally, which procedures are documented and when professional support is needed.
It is not a guaranteed service life or a promise that repair is always economical. Compare the delivered purchase gap with the time and cost you would realistically spend maintaining a grinder. A buyer who will never repair one may value simple daily controls more.
Fit the actual grinder into the morning routine
Measure cupboard clearance with room to lift the hopper lid and remove the grounds container. Think about noise timing in a shared home, the nearest outlet and where a brush and scale will live. We have not measured these units’ sound in your kitchen.
Try your usual beans and brewer during the return period, then check whether the container pours neatly and the controls feel straightforward. Keep the burr chamber dry and follow the exact cleaning manual. A grinder that is easy to use and clean is more likely to earn its space.
Buying in the United States or Canada
Buy a locally rated electrical unit and compare the standard OXO 8717000 with the standard Encore ZCG485. OXO’s integrated-scale models and Baratza’s Encore ESP/ESP Pro are different products. Check seller authorization, local parts supply and applicable support in your country.
The buttons open the named country’s Amazon search results. Match the exact model, size and included parts before ordering. Compare delivered cost, seller and return terms; no fixed price, availability or warranty eligibility is promised.
Questions before ordering
Does the OXO timer measure grams?
No. A timed run is not a weight measurement. Use a suitable scale if dose by mass matters to your recipe.
Should I choose Encore ESP instead?
Consider its espresso-oriented adjustment if espresso is the main job. Compare the exact model’s features and cost rather than assuming all Encores are the same.
Final buying decision
OXO is the convenient value choice when its timer fits your routine and its delivered price is lower. Encore earns a premium for a buyer who values its parts and support path. For daily filter coffee, dose consistency, usable adjustment and cleanup matter more than the setting count alone.