Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, My Indoor Space earns from qualifying purchases through links in this article, at no extra cost to you.
Quick verdict
Choose the compact brush for small crumbs and reachable surfaces. Choose the upright set for regular floor sweeping when a long-handled dustpan suits your routine. Keep an existing broom and pan if they already collect debris comfortably and store neatly.
Research-based buying guide. Information checked October 16, 2026 (Winnipeg). We have not tested these products hands-on; source findings and our buying judgments are identified separately.
OXO compact dustpan and brush
OXO upright sweep set
A tiny brush and a full-size sweep set are not competing versions of exactly the same job. One can live near a work surface for small spills; the other handles a floor area. Start by identifying where you repeatedly need a cleanup tool.
Compare the intended task
| Question | Compact OXO set | OXO upright set |
|---|---|---|
| Handle format | Short hand brush and pan | Full-size broom and long pan handle |
| Likely use | Small reachable debris | Routine floor sweeping |
| Storage question | Drawer or shelf clearance | Tall closet or utility-space fit |
When the compact set is enough
OXO identifies its compact set with countertop use and an angled handle. The brush clips into the pan, covering the bristles for storage. Its listed dimensions are 7.35 by 5.4 by 1.6 inches.
That makes it a plausible choice for a small dry spill near a workspace. Keep cleaning tools appropriate to their surfaces; a brush used on the floor should not become your food-preparation-surface brush. Check the surface maker’s cleaning instructions, especially for delicate finishes.
When the upright set earns the upgrade
The upright model includes a full-size broom and a larger dustpan. OXO describes flagged bristle ends, a flexible pan lip, combing teeth and a pan that locks open for emptying. These are manufacturer design features, not results from our own pickup tests.
A long-handled pan can suit someone who dislikes placing a small pan at floor level. Check the actual handle height against your preferred working position. A single listed overall dimension does not prove the set will be comfortable for every person’s height.
Measure storage before buying both
The upright page lists overall dimensions of 9.5 by 3 by 38.5 inches. Leave enough room to remove the set from the closet without catching its broom head on other supplies. A tool that falls out whenever you open the door is a poor organizational upgrade.
The compact tool can store separately near the task. That is its potential advantage over a broom already in another room. If you would keep both in the same utility closet and use them for the same floor spill, the smaller set may add little.
Who should buy or skip?
Buy compact for repeated small, reachable jobs, or upright for a floor routine that benefits from longer handles. We have not tested fine-dust pickup, pan-to-floor contact on different flooring, or bristle durability.
Skip either when your current broom, dustpan or appropriate vacuum attachment already handles the task well. The best purchase removes a repeated inconvenience. A matching collection is less useful than one tool with the right working height, lip contact and storage location.
Compare listings in your country
These buttons open matching Amazon search results, rather than a guaranteed in-stock offer. Confirm the exact model, seller, included parts, delivered price and return terms. Prices and availability can differ between the United States and Canada.
OXO compact dustpan and brush
OXO upright sweep set
Related guides on My Indoor Space
- Best Cordless Vacuum for a Small Apartment
- Command Broom Grippers vs a Screw-Mounted Mop Rack: Which Should You Buy?
- Bona Premium Spray Mop vs Swiffer PowerMop: Which Costs Less to Keep?