Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, My Indoor Space earns from qualifying purchases through links in this article, at no extra cost to you.
Quick verdict
Choose No-Spill when the trip from sink to freezer and smaller everyday cubes are the main concern. Choose the covered large-cube silicone model when you want its six larger cubes and individual release. Compare freezer fit and cube format before paying for a premium tray.
Research-based buying guide. Information checked October 16, 2026 (Winnipeg). We have not tested these products hands-on; source findings and our buying judgments are identified separately.
OXO No-Spill ice tray
OXO large-cube silicone tray
These trays solve different problems. One emphasizes sealing water in during carrying and storage; the other emphasizes flexible molds for a particular large cube. Buying by the word “silicone” alone misses the differences in cube count and daily handling.
Compare the exact formats
| Question | No-Spill tray | Covered silicone, large cube |
|---|---|---|
| Published output per tray | 14 rounded quarter-ounce cubes | 6 cubes, 1¾-inch square |
| Handling feature | Sealing silicone lid and handle | Flexible tray with support frame |
| Main decision | Carry and storage routine | Large cube format |
When No-Spill is enough
OXO describes a silicone lid that seals water into the No-Spill tray, allowing stacking and angled storage. That can be useful when a crowded freezer or a longer walk makes an ordinary open tray inconvenient.
Follow the filling and sealing instructions. A useful lid still needs correct placement and cleaning. Check whether the seller offers one tray or the cited two-pack before comparing the total number of cubes you can prepare.
When large silicone cubes earn the upgrade
The referenced large-cube model makes six cubes in flexible silicone, with a frame supporting the tray during handling. Choose that version if larger cubes fit the glasses and drinks you regularly use.
Do not treat large cubes as ice that never melts or never dilutes a drink. We have not tested melting, freezing time or release. Decide whether the format is enjoyable and practical rather than accepting an absolute performance promise from a sales description.
Check size, count and freezer clearance
OXO also sells a covered silicone cocktail-cube version that produces many smaller cubes. Similar product photographs can hide a very different output. Match the full name and cube dimensions, not simply the brand and lid color.
Measure the usable flat shelf area, stacking height and the space needed to remove a tray without tilting other food. Then check whether six large cubes cover your usual need. A second inexpensive tray in the right format can be more useful than one premium tray with too few compartments.
Who should buy or skip?
Buy No-Spill for the sealed-carry workflow or the large silicone model for its cube format. Check the exact care directions: No-Spill specifies top-rack dishwasher use, while the cited large silicone tray is listed as dishwasher-safe. Keep working trays if they fit the freezer, release the amount you need and are easy to fill. Neither upgrade is essential just because you use ice daily.
Compare listings in your country
These buttons open matching Amazon search results, rather than a guaranteed in-stock offer. Confirm the exact model, seller, included parts, delivered price and return terms. Prices and availability can differ between the United States and Canada.
OXO No-Spill ice tray
OXO large-cube silicone tray
Related guides on My Indoor Space
- Best Countertop Ice Maker: What to Know Before You Buy
- Manual vs Electric Citrus Juicer: When Is the Motor Worth It?
- OXO Angled vs Pyrex Glass Measuring Cup: Which Should You Buy?