As an Amazon Associate, My Indoor Space earns from qualifying purchases.
Quick verdict
Choose DrawerStore Bamboo when its narrow footprint fits your knife collection and you accept the wood-care routine. Choose OXO when its removable tray and small/large slot arrangement suit your knives and cleaning preferences. Test the loaded height: an empty organizer fitting in the drawer is not enough.
Research-based buying guide, checked October 18, 2026. We have not tested these products hands-on. Manufacturer specifications and attributed outside findings are distinguished from our buying judgments.
Who should buy or skip
Buy if: you want designated blade storage inside a drawer and can keep that area accessible and appropriate for sharp tools.
Skip if: your knives have unusually broad blades or bulky handles that do not fit, the drawer is too shallow or you expect a knife count to guarantee compatibility.
Compare the choices
| Choice | Choose it for | Main tradeoff |
|---|---|---|
| DrawerStore Bamboo 85169 | A narrow, tiered bamboo format | Needs wiping, drying and periodic oiling |
| OXO Compact Knife Organizer | Separate small/large slots and a removable tray | Check actual blade and handle fit |
| Individual suitable blade guards | A small collection with varied shapes | Each knife needs its own correctly fitted cover |
Count your actual knife types
Joseph Joseph lists up to nine knives and blades up to 9 inches/23 cm for the bamboo model. OXO describes slots for five small and four large knives. Neither number proves that a cleaver, thick-handled knife or every short paring knife will fit well.
Lay out the knives you use most and measure blade length, blade height and handle bulk. A slot can accept the blade while leaving its handle at an awkward angle. Prioritize easy, controlled removal over reaching the advertised maximum count.
Check width, depth and loaded clearance
The bamboo model’s stated dimensions are about 39.7 cm deep and 11.5 cm wide. Joseph Joseph specifies a minimum drawer height of 8.5 cm for this exact product. Confirm the selected SKU because plastic and large bamboo versions differ.
Measure the drawer’s usable interior and the opening it passes through. Handles may sit above the tray, and rails can reduce the practical clearance. Close the drawer slowly in a careful fit test; do not force a loaded organizer under an obstruction.
Choose the maintenance you will keep doing
Joseph Joseph says to wipe the bamboo clean, dry it by hand, avoid soaking and oil it regularly with a food-safe oil. That is a meaningful care commitment in a kitchen where wet knives often go straight from sink to drawer.
OXO’s tray removes for cleaning. Follow its actual care instructions rather than assuming a removable component is automatically dishwasher-safe. For either organizer, store knives clean and dry and inspect the channels for trapped residue.
Storage should improve access, not hide a poor fit
A dedicated organizer can reduce loose blades moving around in a drawer. It does not make any placement safe: the drawer’s location, who can access it and the way each knife is seated still matter. Keep sharp tools in appropriate household storage.
We have not tested these models’ grip, blade-edge protection or long-term wear. During a return period, check removal with the real knives and make sure the tray stays in place in normal use. A smaller well-fitted collection is more useful than a crowded drawer full of difficult handles.
Buying in the United States or Canada
Match DrawerStore Bamboo Compact 85169 rather than a plastic, large bamboo or cutlery model. OXO also sells other drawer organizers, so confirm that the listing is its knife tray with the intended slot layout. Check current dimensions and local return terms in the US or Canada.
The buttons open the named country’s Amazon search results. Match the exact model, size and included parts before ordering. Compare delivered cost, seller and return terms; no fixed price, availability or warranty eligibility is promised.
Questions before ordering
Does bamboo mean dishwasher-safe?
No. Joseph Joseph specifies wiping, hand drying, no soaking and regular food-safe oiling for this model.
Should I choose by maximum knife count?
Use the count only as a starting point. Blade shape, handle clearance and safe removal determine whether your collection fits.
Final buying decision
Bamboo is the sensible choice when its narrow footprint and appearance justify the care routine. OXO is the practical alternative when its removable insert and slot arrangement match your knives. Buy only after checking the complete loaded drawer, not just the organizer’s outline.