As an Amazon Associate, My Indoor Space earns from qualifying purchases.
Quick verdict
Choose the standard Joseph Joseph Caddy when a dishcloth rail and separate sponge area will organize your actual tools. Choose OXO’s stainless caddy for a compact upright brush-and-sponge arrangement with a removable divider. If you need a big detergent bottle inside the organizer, measure it before buying either.
Research-based buying guide, checked October 18, 2026. We have not tested these products hands-on. Manufacturer specifications and attributed outside findings are distinguished from our buying judgments.
Who should buy or skip
Buy if: you have a few regularly used washing tools that need a defined place and you will empty the collected water.
Skip if: you have no spare counter area, need automatic drainage into the sink or expect a caddy to eliminate sponge cleaning and replacement.
Compare the choices
| Choice | Choose it for | Main tradeoff |
|---|---|---|
| Joseph Joseph Caddy standard | Dishcloth rail, sponge plate and bottle/brush space | Wider layout needs a clear counter footprint |
| OXO stainless caddy | Upright brush and sponge storage | No dedicated dishcloth rail |
| In-sink organizer | Preserving counter space | Needs a compatible sink and attachment method |
Start with a tool list
Joseph Joseph’s standard Caddy has a main bottle-and-brush compartment, a cloth rail and a sponge plate. OXO uses a ventilated removable divider to separate brushes and sponges. Choose the arrangement around your daily tools instead of buying a container and then shopping for things to fill it.
Measure the base of a detergent bottle if it must be stored inside. Tall pump heads also need room to operate without hitting the faucet or wall. A manufacturer example bottle does not establish fit for every refillable dispenser.
Compare the loaded footprint beside the faucet
Joseph Joseph lists its standard Caddy at 21 x 11.5 x 13.5 cm. OXO lists 5.6 x 3.8 x 5.5 inches for the stainless model. Check the exact dimensions and orientation against the available space, including the movement of a pull-out spray hose.
A cloth on the rail can occupy space beyond the empty organizer. A brush handle can lean against a window ledge. Put the real items in a mock layout on the counter before deciding that a smaller published footprint necessarily gives a neater result.
Collected water still needs emptying
The standard Joseph Joseph Caddy has a concealed reservoir; OXO has a drip tray with a pour spout. Neither is being recommended here as a permanently plumbed drain. Add checking and emptying the reservoir to your normal sink-cleaning routine.
Ventilation and separation can help tools dry, but we have not measured drying times or hygiene performance. Avoid promises that a storage purchase sanitizes a sponge. Clean the tools and organizer according to their instructions and replace worn items as needed.
Buy the right version and care for it accordingly
Joseph Joseph makes standard, large and other sink organizers with different layouts. The standard Caddy page lists dishwasher-safe care and dismantling for cleaning. Do not transfer that instruction to another version without checking.
OXO’s stainless caddy has a removable divider and tray; use the exact model’s care instructions rather than assuming a metal exterior makes every component dishwasher-safe. We have not tested finish durability, residue buildup or long-term fit after repeated washing.
Buying in the United States or Canada
Match Joseph Joseph standard Caddy 85022 or its equivalent colour SKU, not Caddy Large or the older Tower. Match OXO Stainless Steel Sink Caddy 13192100 rather than another sinkware holder. Compare exact seller photographs and locally applicable return terms.
The buttons open the named country’s Amazon search results. Match the exact model, size and included parts before ordering. Compare delivered cost, seller and return terms; no fixed price, availability or warranty eligibility is promised.
Questions before ordering
Does either drain automatically into the sink?
The models compared here collect water in a reservoir or tray that needs emptying. Do not assume a permanent sink-draining spout.
Which is better for a damp dishcloth?
The Joseph Joseph standard model has a dedicated rail. Check that your cloth can hang without bunching or touching nearby wet surfaces.
Final buying decision
Joseph Joseph is the clearer choice for a cloth-and-sponge station with room for its wider layout. OXO suits a smaller upright tool group and a stainless appearance. Choose neither if the real problem is lack of counter space; compare an appropriate in-sink organizer first.